Who's Who in Pennsylvania's Underground Railroad

Documentation: Boyd Crumrine, History of Washington County, 1882; Earle Robert Forrest, History of Washington County, Pennsylvania, 1926, p. 426.

While working as a barber in Waynesburg, Greene County, Ermine Cain also supervised the movement of fugitive slaves through his area to the next station, which was west to Rogersville, Center Township.  Cain reputedly sheltered and fed fugitives at a nearby spring in a dense thicket before hiding them in a lumber drying house.  He would then send them to Rogersville.  From Rogersville, the freedom seekers were sent on a more northerly route to West Alexander, in Washington County, then to West Middletown (see Asbury, William, and McKeever, Matthew).  At that point, some accounts have fugitives from Cain's station being taken to Samuel Dorsey in Washington.

Documentation: Edward H. Magill, “When Men Were Sold, Reminiscences of the Underground Railroad in Bucks County and Its Managers,” in A Collection of Papers Read Before the Bucks County Historical Society 2(1909): 493-520.

Documentation: W. J. McKnight, MD, A Pioneer Outline History of Northwestern Pennsylvania, 1905.

Isaac P. and Hannah Carmalt's Clayville station received fugitives from Centre and Clearfield Counties, according to his daughter. The route was fron "Centre County, near Bellefonte, kept by a friend by the name of Iddings, who sent them to the next station, which was Grampian Hills, from thence to our house."  He led freedom seekers to Christopher Fogle in Brookville, near the center of the county. Carmalt was threatened for his activities by some neighbors who were sympathetic to pro-slavery powers.

Documentation: Gregory Wilson/Warren County Historical Society, "Underground Railroad Sites in Warren County, PA," 2005, http://www.paundergroundrailroad.com/sites.htm, accessed January 6, 2006.

English-born Joah Carter received fugitives from Corry, Erie County, and Tidioute and hid them on his property until it was safe to send them onward.  His home was located between Sugar Grove and Lottsville.  He is shown on the 1850 census as a 64-year-old farmer, living with Elizabeth, age 61, also born in England, Joseph, age 21 and Joshua, age 19.  Both boys were born in New York.

Documentation: A. J. Davis, History of Clarion County, Pennsylvania, 1887, p. 122.

Documentation: G. Craig Caba, Episodes of Gettysburg and the Underground Railroad, 1998, p. 81.

Anti-slavery lecturer, activist and editor of The National Era, William L. Chaplin backed his words with action by transporting fugitive slaves from Washington to the Adams County UGRR station of James McAllister on Wolf Hill.  A McAllister family member who witnessed many of the deliveries estimated that Chaplin brought about twenty fugitives to the farm.  His last trip, in 1850, was observed, and his carriage was pursued and captured in Montgomery County, Maryland, by Washington police, who charged him with helping two slaves of U.S. Representatives Robert Toombs and Alexander Stephens to escape.  The slaves were to have been sheltered at McAllister's farm and forwarded to Quaker William Wright at York Springs, but the escape plan was foiled by slave catchers who caught up with them before they could reach Pennsylvania.

Documentation: Local lore, obituary of David Chester

George and Marie Chester operated an oyster house and restaurant on the north side of Market Street near Third. Now marked with a state historical marker for the birthplace of Thomas Morris Chester, a son of George and Marie, the site was a gathering place for anti-slavery and abolitionist activists. Abolitionist newspapers The North Star, The Liberator and others could be found here. Only the obituary of David Chester, son of George and Marie, notes Underground Railroad activity, although it is a widely held belief that the Chester home and restaurant was a station. After George Chester died in 1859, his wife Marie purchased a home at 69 Chestnut Street and moved the restaurant there. It later relocated to 305 Chestnut Street. Neither of these later locations have been associated with URR activity.  See the 1850 census listing for the George Chester family.

Documentation: Richard L. Tritt, "The Underground Railroad at Boiling Springs," in At a Place Called the Boiling Springs, Richard L. Tritt and Randy Watts, editors, 1995, pp. 111-117.

George Cole, a free African American resident of Chambersburg, found a group of thirteen slaves who had run away from Williamsport, Maryland in October 1847.  Cole guided them north through Shippensburg, following a route that used iron furnaces as safe havens.  He stopped with them at Miller's Furnace, Huntsdale, and Salome Forge, then intended to continue to Ege's Forge at Boiling Springs but found too many people around, so delivered his fugitives to the barn of Daniel Kaufman.  The slaveholder eventually found out that Kaufman has used his barn to shelter the slaves, and successfully sued him for $4,000 in 1852.

Documentation: W. J. McKnight, MD, A Pioneer Outline History of Northwestern Pennsylvania, 1905.

Christopher Fogle, in Brookville, would forward slaves to William R. Coon in Clarington, Barnett Township. Coon would ferry them across the Clarion River, where he would shelter, feed and tend to them before sending them to the next station in Forest County.  From there they would be sent to Warren, Pennsylvania.

Documentation: Elizabeth Agnes Kilgore, "History of Mercer," unpublished manuscript, 1930; History of Mercer County, 1888.

Documentation: Henry W. Storey, History of Cambria County, 1907, p. 186-192.